Skip to content

About this Episode

GBA Case History Series – Case History #98 - How Did That Get There?

Summary

Member Firm provides geotechnical engineering services and CoMET for a new project on the site of an existing shopping center. CoMET services were provided “as needed” for demolition of the shopping center. A few years after the completion of construction, one of the three new retaining walls deflected significantly. Investigation of the backfill led to some surprises. On cue, the owner sued to reclaim the repair costs

Our Hosts:

Elizabeth is the Principal Geotechnical Engineer at JLT Consultants in Boise, Idaho. Elizabeth has performed and/or assisted with numerous geotechnical investigations throughout Idaho, Oregon, Washington, and Wyoming managing projects, providing geotechnical design, project quality control, cost and value engineering, and evaluating geotechnical constructability issues.

Abi is a Project Consultant at SME experienced in managing a variety of steel, concrete, coatings, and nondestructive testing projects. She specializes in managing projects related to DOT fabrication quality assurance reviews but also supports project managers throughout SME’s various service groups.

Lessons Learned:

  • Beyond the Go/No-go Analysis
  • Quality Assurance Is Not Quality Control
  • Defining Terms Is Essential
  • No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
  • Spot-checking Elevates Risk
  • Reusing Existing Materials May Create Special Risks
  • Constructors May Not Implement Adequate QC
  • Effective CoMET Documentation Describes What Was and Was Not Observed
  • Communication at All Levels Can Be Critical
  • Rely on Experienced Legal Guidance
  • “Agreeable” Experts Are Always Available
  • Claims Are a Business Issue
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution Works

Calls-to-action:

Subscribe

This episode was produced by the following GBA Members:

Transcript

Case History 98

Liz

Welcome to the GBA Case History Series, brought to you by the GBA Podcast. My name is Elizabeth Brown, and I'm a principal geotechnical engineer at JLT Consultants.

Abi

And I'm Abi Corbett, a project consultant at SME. So today's episode is a wild ride. We're talking about a shopping center redevelopment project that has everything: old fill, big box tenants, tight schedules, reused materials, a contractor with, let's call it creative quality control, and a phrase that should haunt every engineer's dream, "As needed."

Liz

So if you've ever wondered how two words can cost a firm 50 grand and years of stress, buckle up, 'cause today we're diving into case history number 98.

Read Full Transcript Hide Full Transcript

Abi

Okay, picture this. A national shopping center owner wants to demolish 75% of a 35-year-old mall and rebuild it as a shiny new retail center. Big project, big tenants, big schedule pressure.

Liz

And the site? Well, it's 60-plus acres of old fill. They're gonna have some new cuts, new fills, three retaining walls up to 25 feet tall. Two of those walls are gonna support, like, these big box buildings. So I mean, really, this, it's not medium risk. This is, you know, like, CEO gets involved type of risk.

Abi

Right, and that's actually exactly what happened. The member firm CEO oversaw the proposal because the risks really were that high.

Liz

And then the owner ignored the firm's contract and sent their own, which did not contain a limitation of liability. So the CEO pushed back and eventually they negotiated a $1 million limitation if the firm also provided the CoMET services.

Abi

And here's where some trouble is gonna start. The contract said CoMET services would be provided as needed. No one defined it, not the owner, not the construction manager, not the geotechnical firm.

Liz

Oof. That phrase becomes the ghost that ends up haunting this entire project

Abi

And it leads us to our first big lesson. A go, no-go analysis isn't enough. So they identified some risks pretty early. That's why they got the CEO involved. But once they said go, they didn't follow through with that same rigor. The risk management thing, it's a process, not just a checkbox.

Liz

Exactly. And if you know a project is high risk, you can't afford vague language. You need clarity and documentation and communication at every step. So I mean, that as needed really should have been further defined.

Abi

Yes, 100% agree. Okay, so construction begins and the owner hires an excavation contractor known for being, quote, "bottom line focused." And by that, we mean one of their managers bragged about burying unsuitable materials when no one was watching

Liz

Oh yeah. Everybody knows that kind of contractor, and I think if you've been in the industry for any amount of time, everyone knows who that contractor is, unfortunately. So I mean, that's the kind of thing that really makes geotechnical engineers, wake up at 3:00 AM in a cold sweat.

Abi

Yeah. Definitely to say the least on that one. And the member firm assigned a senior principal and an experienced field rep to oversee construction. But the owner didn't just give them a blank check, so the team had to constantly decide what they're gonna observe and what they just basically have to skip.

Liz

Right. So I mean, I think a positive note here is that the firm recognized the risk, right? And so they made sure that they did have, a senior principal and that experienced field rep, right? They weren't putting the one-year-outta-school guy out of there, right? They made sure, "Hey, we're gonna get, some good quality people out on this site." And really here's where another lesson comes in, is that QA is not QC. So the CoMET firms provide quality assurance, not quality control. They're not the contractor's police force. But if the owner or contractor thinks that you're doing QC, you're already in trouble

Abi

Yeah, that's something I like to really get out in the open first thing in forefront with my projects is like very clearly say that QC is responsible for QC. I am just spot checking.

Liz

Right

Abi

And in this case, because no one defined as-needed, the field rep had to make judgment calls. He decided the cantilevered retaining wall, the one that's supporting landscaping, it, it was low priority. He skipped density testing and only did two spot checks.

Liz

I get his field judgment, right? It was a lower priority item, less risk to, life and limb type issues there. But really this kind of leads to another one of our lessons is that spot checking elevates risk. Spot checking assumes that the contractor is honest and consistent, but this contractor had a history of cutting corners.

Abi

Yeah. And there's a kicker. Pulverized asphalt and clay look similar from a distance. So reusing materials is great, environmentally friendly, cost-effective, but it creates opportunities for confusion or maybe even cheating.

Liz

Which kind of leads us to another lesson is that reused materials require heightened observation. There's so many different things that could happen or go wrong or, you know, blending of materials or things of that nature. So if the client declines that level of observation, right, that heightened observation, then really that needs to be documented, and to document it, I mean in writing, right? Like every single time.

Abi

Yeah. Like high, high, high focus on it. But the project finished, everyone celebrated, grand opening, smiles, break out the champagne.

Liz

Oh, yeah. But then, dun, dun, dun, the wall moved.

Abi

Right. A few years later, the property manager calls and quote, "One of the retaining walls is failing. Come figure it out." End quote.

Liz

So a 100-foot stretch had deflected. The keyways between the segments had sheared, and really the initial suspicion was hydrostatic pressure from a clogged drain

Abi

But when they drilled borings and installed groundwater monitoring wells, they found something much worse.

Liz

Yeah, unfortunately there was clay in the backfill. So what they found was alternating layers of pulverized asphalt and clay, even though clay was explicitly prohibited.

Abi

Contractor cheated. And because the field rep wasn't, I really couldn't watch that wall very closely. No one caught it.

Liz

Right. And so here's another lesson is the, the constructors may not implement adequate QC, like even the good ones. I mean, with schedule pressure, cost pressure, or just plain habit can lead to bad decisions.

Abi

Yeah, especially if you're feeling like it's a status quo kind of job. So the owner does need the wall fixed before they wanna sell the property. They set a $300,000 budget, hired a contractor, and the member firm did CoMET for this repair.

Liz

And based on those observations, the firm concluded that, hey, improper backfill was the primary cause of failure.

Abi

So here comes the lawsuit. First, the excavator and construction manager, and then the member firm.

Liz

Well, and as usual, right, with the lawsuits, everyone's pointing fingers at everybody else, right? The construction manager said, "Not our fault." And the excavator said, "We did what the geotechnical engineer told us." They even claimed that the member firm had someone on site, quote, "At all times."

Abi

Which is just absolutely false.

Liz

Right. So the member firm argued, number one, "Hey, they can't be everywhere at once." Number two, "They weren't required to observe everything." Number three, "The owner knew the CoMET scope was limited." And number four, "The contractor was responsible for meeting specs regardless of observation."

Abi

And here's a huge lesson. Effective documentation must describe what was not observed. Silence implies oversight, and oversight implies responsibility.

Liz

Right. So experts weighed in. One blamed clay, one said the distress was cosmetic, one blamed the wall design. Nobody agreed.

Abi

Imagine that. Which, I mean, it brings us to just another lesson. Agreeable experts are always available. Some experts really will say anything for the right fee. Their testimony can get kind of muddy and maybe even prolong a dispute.

Liz

Right. So in this case, the parties went to mediation, right? "Hey, let's get this settled out." And here's where another lesson hits hard is that litigation is not about truth, it's about persuasion. You need experienced construction claims attorneys who understand how to defend technical professionals.

Abi

Right. And the mediator's goal here wasn't to find who was right. It was to find a settlement everyone hated equally. So the excavator ended up paying $115,000. Our member firm paid 22,500, and the owner reduced its claim by $150,000.

Liz

Whew. And the member firm spent about $50,000 total, including unbilled time

Abi

Billed time is always such a big kicker

Liz

It is

Abi

All right, let's run back on all those lessons that we talked about throughout the case.

Liz

All right, so lesson one is risk management doesn't stop at go/no go. If you identify a project as high risk, you need heightened communication, documentation, and clarity throughout the entire project.

Abi

Big emphasis on entire.

Liz

Right.

Abi

All right, lesson two, QA is not QC. If an owner or a contractor thinks in any way you're doing QC, you are in trouble. We need to educate these people early and often that QA is not QC.

Liz

Right. And really by doing that, you're really helping to elevate the geoprofession as a whole. Like educating is to, you know, the proper way there. So lesson three, define your terms, especially quote, "As needed." So ambiguity is a liability magnet. If you don't define it, a lawyer will, and more than likely it won't be in your favor.

Abi

Ew. And look, lesson number four, no good deed goes unpunished. If you're trying to save a a client money by reducing your observation, it can backfire unless a client is explicitly approving it in writing.

Liz

Right. Writing is key. You want everything in writing. So lesson five, spot checking increases risk. If you're not there full-time, you must document what you did not see.

Abi

Lesson number six: reuse materials require vigilance. Pulverized asphalt looks like soil. Clay looks like soil. Cheating is just kind of easy in this case.

Liz

Agreed. Lesson seven: contractors may not implement adequate QC. Even honest contractors make mistakes. Some make choices.

Abi

Human element.

Liz

Great

Abi

Lesson eight: documentation must include what was not observed. Daily reports need to reflect reality, not just optimism.

Liz

And lesson nine, communication is everything. Weekly check-ins aren't enough on a complex project.

Abi

One of my favorite lessons, number 10, litigation is brutal. Opposing counsel is going to twist facts and you're going to need strong legal guidance

Liz

And building that relationship early with your legal counsel is a great idea. So lesson 11, experts can be bought. Prepare for testimony that contradicts reality

Abi

Lesson 12: claims are business decisions. A lot of times settling is just gonna be cheaper rather than fighting the fight and winning

Liz

Right. It's all about risk management there. So lesson 13, mediation works even if it feels unfair. It's about closure, not justice. As the CEO said, it can feel like, quote, "legal thievery," but it's cheaper than trial

Abi

I like the way that he put that.

Liz

Right

Abi

So that's about it for case history number 98, a perfect storm of unclear scope, reused materials, contractor shortcuts, and assumptions that went unspoken.

Liz

If you take nothing else away, let it be this. Define your scope in writing every time.

Abi

Thanks for joining us. Share this episode with anyone who's had to explain the difference between QA and QC.

Liz

And that concludes this episode of the Case History series brought to you by the GBA podcast. I hope you were able to take away some useful information that will help you and others at your firm make good risk-based decisions in the future. If this episode resonated with you or if you have a potential case history, we want to hear your story. Email us at info@geoprofessional.org or comment on our LinkedIn post.

Download Transcript